Analysis

Making Aadhaar accessible for everyone

The Supreme Court threatened the Union with contempt to ensure accessibility for persons with visual impairment.

Sometimes, the judiciary aims to correct executive inaction by threatening punitive measures, without actually invoking them. One such judicial strategy was evident on 16 November, when the Supreme Court heard a Miscellaneous Application filed by Advocate Amar Jain.

Jain, who is visually-impared, sought the Court’s intervention after a private bank rejected his credit-card application. He alleged that the Court’s April 2025 directions to remove impediments faced by people with blindness or low vision in completing Aadhaar face-authentication and e-KYC processes were not implemented.

The Bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K.V. Chandran orally threatened the Union government and other authorities with contempt while their written order condoned the delay in filing the application. 

The constitutional right to digital access

In April 2025, a Bench of Justices Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan had considered digital KYC challenges faced by acid attack survivors and people with visual disabilities in Pragya Prasun v Union of India and Amar Jain v Union of India. The petitioners claimed that they could not independently access financial and telecommunications services because of the insistence on eye-blinking tests, facial recognition, handwritten signatures, and visual verification. They alleged that these obstacles affected their ability to open a bank account, get a mobile connection, obtain insurance, or receive government benefits.

The Bench issued 20 directions. Regulated entities were required to conduct periodic accessibility audits, involve blind users in testing applications and websites, allow alternatives to eye-blinking tests, accept thumb impressions, and provide accessible verification procedures.

Importantly, it also directed the creation of dedicated grievance redressal mechanisms with human review of KYC applications rejected on accessibility grounds. A designated officer could, on a case-by-case basis, override an automated rejection.

Compliance remains a challenge

On 14 August 2025, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) issued a circular directing banks, non-banking financial companies and other regulated entities to comply with the judgement. Its KYC directions for commercial banks say that facial gestures such as eye blinking are unnecessary to establish liveness, or the customer’s physical presence, during video-based verification. Banks must also take account of customers’ special needs.  

This circular was subsequently withdrawn, to consolidate its scattered regulatory instructions. On 28 November 2025, the RBI incorporated the requirement to comply with the judgement into its consolidated Responsible Business Conduct Directions for commercial banks and non-banking financial companies. It expressly requires banks to comply with the Supreme Court’s 30 April 2025 judgement in Pragya Prasun and Amar Jain). 

A major sticking point is the difference between UIDAI’s Aadhaar face-authentication mechanism and the verification methods used by banks and other service providers. The RBI’s clarification on eye blinking relates to customer identification through video KYC, but barriers to Aadhaar face authentication remain unaddressed, particularly where a service provider has built its customer process around a specific application or biometric method. UIDAI develops and regulates the Aadhaar authentication system, while banks, telecom companies and others decide how to incorporate it into their services.

The 2025 judgement considered this shared responsibility. Thus, one of the Court’s directions to RBI was that it should issue guidelines to all regulated entities to adopt and incorporate alternative modes for verifying the “liveness” or capturing a “live photograph” of the customers, for the purpose of conducting Digital KYC / e-KYC beyond the traditional “blinking of eyes” to ensure inclusivity and user convenience. Another direction asked all regulated entities to mandatorily undergo periodical accessibility audit by certified accessibility professionals and involve persons with blindness in user acceptance testing phase while designing any app or website or in case of any new feature being launched. 

Implications for access to welfare benefits

A separate application has challenged the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas’s move to make biometric Aadhaar authentication mandatory for subsidised domestic LPG refills from 1 October 2026. 

The Aadhaar Act, 2016 already includes safeguards against authentication failures. Section 4(6) requires requesting entities to inform users about alternative, viable means of identification and prohibits denying service solely because a person refuses or cannot authenticate. The proviso to Section 8(2) requires viable alternatives when authentication fails due to illness, injury, infirmity or technical or other reasons. Regulation 5 of the Aadhaar (Authentication and Offline Verification) Regulations, 2021 also deals with alternative identification.

In Pragya Prasun, the Supreme Court held that digital accessibility is a constitutional imperative. The current proceedings will test how this principle is enforced as biometric identification becomes part of public services and financial transactions. For Jain and others like him, the test will be whether they can authenticate their identity on their own terms without relying on others for assistance.

Exit mobile version