Lighting of Karthigai Deepam | Petitioners seek interim stay on lighting at Deepathoon

Lighting of Karthigai Deepam at Thirupparankundram Hill

Judges: Aravind Kumar J, V.M. Pancholi J

Today, a Bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul Pancholi heard a batch of pleas seeking stay of the Madras High Court judgement which upheld lighting of the Karthigai Deepam at the stone pillar—identified as the Deepathoon—near the top of the Thirupparankundram Hill. 

A Single Judge of the Madras High Court directed lighting of the lamp at Deepathoon on Karthigai Deepam Day, an order later upheld by a Division Bench. Contempt proceedings arose in the High Court following continued non-implementation of the orders. The authorities argued that the Deepathoon is situated on top of the hill, very near the Sulthan Sikkanthar Avulia Dargha, claiming that the proximity could risk public peace. The Madras High Court made critical remarks stating that the state government was “projecting a tenacious plea of disturbance to public order.” It added that the lighting of the Deepam near the Dargha was an opportunity to “bridge the difference between these two communities”. It dismissed the state’s fear of disturbance as “ridiculous and hard to believe”.

The Hill has two peaks :one houses the Dargha near the pillar, and the other houses the temple, 199.5 meters away. The property boundaries were settled by a 1923 Decree. Notably, the parties seeking interim stay disagreed over the pillar’s ownership. The Tamil Nadu government maintained that the pillar was part of the temple while others claimed that it was part of the Dargha. 

Earlier this week, the state filed an affidavit stating that for over 150 years the Karthigai Deepam had been lit exclusively at the Deepa Mandapam, never on the stone pillar. Petitioners argued that no such custom existed.

The urgent interim stay was sought ahead of this year’s Karthigai Deepam, scheduled for 24 November 2026.

Petitioners: Let “status-quo” be maintained 

Senior Advocate Jaideep Gupta appeared for the Commissioner. According to practice, a person who wants to light the lamp at any other place on the Hill has to take permission from the temple. The Temple will allow it after taking approval from the Commissioner. In this case, the lighting of the lamp at a different place was not allowed resulting in a writ petition at Madras High Court, resulting in the Orders currently under challenge.

Gupta argued that the original petitioner had failed to establish any custom entitling him to light the lamp at Deepathoon, or to seek a direction requiring the Devasthanam, the temple administration, to do so. Without a pre-existing right or custom, a mandamus seeking such a direction could not stand. He clarified that the precedents only recognise the custom of lighting the lamp at its original location, adding that allowing it at Deepathoon would establish a new custom entirely.

Senior Advocate Shekhar Naphade argued that a “natural division” exists between the Temple and the Dargha, which the impugned Order disrupted, risking a breach of public peace. He contended that the Madras High Court erred in noting that the lamp was lit atop the hill, where the Dargha is situated. Submitting that “status-quo” involved lighting the lamp elsewhere, he prayed for an interim stay on the Order to preserve it. 

The Supreme Court will continue hearing arguments tomorrow at 2 PM.

Exit mobile version