Analysis
SCO.LR | 2026 | Volume 11 | Issue 3
In this Issue, we identify five bonus judgements delivered by the Supreme Court in November 2026

Volume 11 Issue 3 of the Supreme Court Observer Law Reports is here.
With the Supreme Court on Diwali break, we took the opportunity to identify five bonus decisions from the first week of November. This Issue contains judgements on:
- Action against a judicial officer
- Evidentiary value of expert opinions during conviction
- OBC Creamy layer
- National Book Trust as ‘State’ under Article 12
- Intestate succession under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956
As always, SCO.LR judgements come with concise and accurate summaries, clean and well-formatted judgements with linking features for better readability and ease of research.
**********
The Supreme Court Observer Law Reports
SCO.LR | Volume 11 | Issue 3
Bonus Judgements from first week of November
**********
Appropriate Forum for Action Against a Judicial Officer
In Re: XXX, a Judicial Officer in the District Judge Cadre of Rajasthan Judicial Services
2 November 2026
Citation: 2026 INSC 1188 | 2026 SCO.LR 11(3)[11]
Bench: Justices Sandeep Mehta and D.K. Upadhyaya
The Supreme Court reiterated that High Court action against a judicial officer under Article 227 of the Constitution must follow appropriate procedure on the administrative and not judicial side.
In 2019, an FIR was lodged against two adults and a minor person under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012. The trials were conducted separately in accordance with the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015. The accused were convicted to 20 years rigorous imprisonment by way of two separate judgements pronounced by the Special Judge, POCSO Act Cases, Jhunjhunu. The Rajasthan High Court rejected the minor’s appeal for suspension of sentence but found overlapping and “copy-pasted” content in both judgements. The High Court recorded adverse remarks against the Special Judge and directed her to receive training on judgement writing from the Rajasthan Judicial Academy. The officer approached the Supreme Court submitting that special courts have limited resources and have statutory mandates to dispose of cases in a time-bound manner.
The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s remarks and directions. It held that the judicial officer was not provided an opportunity to explain and therefore the Order violated the principles of natural justice. Differentiating criticism from adverse remarks, it noted that High Courts must refrain from passing strictures against judicial officers when deciding matters on the judicial side.
Key words/phrases: Convictions under Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012—Trial for minor accused conducted separately under Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015—Separate judgements—Minor appeals against conviction dismissed—Rajasthan High Court finds overlapping content in both judgements—Directs training at National Judicial Academy on Judgement writing—Records adverse remarks—Supreme Court appeal—Supervisory power of High Courts—Article 227—Order set aside—Action to proceed on administrative side—No opportunity to show cause—Principles of Natural Justice violated.
Read the Judgement here.
**********
Evidentiary Value of Expert Opinion
Goverdhan v State of Rajasthan
3 November 2023
Citations: 2026 INSC 1190 | 2026 SCO.LR 11(3)[12]
Bench: Justices Sandeep Mehta and D.K. Upadhyaya
The Supreme Court held that an expert’s report cannot be relied upon to establish the details of a crime unless the expert undergoes cross-examination by the prosecution.
The appellant was convicted under Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 for the offense of abetment to suicide of his wife in 2016. The appellant was tried by the Additional Sessions Jugde, Jaipur, where the prosecution maintained that the deceased committed suicide after the appellant sent four letters to her, containing threatening and abusive language, leading to the decline of her mental state. The prosecution relied on the report of a handwriting expert, who affirmed that the writing matched that of the appellant. The trial court’s conviction was upheld by the Rajasthan High Court. The appellant approached the Supreme Court arguing that an expert opinion cannot conclusively establish the crime without adequate corroboration.
The Supreme Court set aside the High Court decision, noting that expert opinion cannot be reliable evidence unless such expert is examined by the prosecution in a cross-examination. Further, the prosecution must discharge the burden of proving that the abetment took place beyond reasonable doubt.
Key words/phrases: Abetment to suicide—Section 306—Indian Penal Code, 1860—Letters aiding abetment—Handwriting expert—Expert report—Conviction of the accused—Appeal—Expert opinion cannot by itself establish crime—Supreme Court—Expert opinion must be cross-examined—Prosecution to discharge burden of proof—Beyond reasonable doubt.
Read the Judgement here.
**********
OBC Creamy Layer Determination in Civil Services Selection
Union of India v Rohith Nathan
6 November 2026
Citations: 2026 INSC 1201 | 2026 SCO.LR 11(3)[13]
Bench: Justices P.S. Narasimha and R. Mahadevan
The Supreme Court held that its interpretation of the 1993 Office Memorandum on determining the OBC creamy layer is binding under Article 141.
On 11 March 2026, the Supreme Court rejected the mechanical exclusion of OBC candidates based on parental salary. It held that a 1994 Office Memorandum, which explicitly excluded salary from the income test for determining creamy layer status, cannot be altered by the 2004 letter, which counted salary income of PSU employees when determining whether their posts were equivalent to government posts. The Union sought clarification that the judgement would not reopen completed selections and appointments, and sought permission to complete service allocation for the Civil Services Examination, 2025 under the earlier criteria.
The Supreme Court clarified that the relief granted concerned the respondent candidates and intervenors and did not require a general revision of concluded selections, appointments or seniority. Pending claims of similarly placed persons may be considered on their own merits. However, since service allocation for candidates selected through the 2025 examination remained pending, the Court directed that it be governed by the creamy-layer principle as laid down in its March judgement.
Key words/phrases: OBC reservation—Creamy layer determination—1993 Office Memorandum—Mechanical exclusion based on parental salary rejected—March 2026 judgement—Completed selections and appointments before judgement protected from reopening—Pending claims to be considered on merits—CSE 2025 service allocation still pending—March 2026 interpretation applicable—Government free to formulate creamy-layer policy
Read the Judgment here.
**********
National Book Trust as “State” Under Article 12
The Chairman, National Book Trust of India v A.R. Abdul Gaffar
6 November 2026
Citation: 2026 INSC 1202| 2026 SCO.LR 11(3)[14]
Bench: Justices P.K. Mishra and A.G. Masih
The Supreme Court held that the National Book Trust is an “other authority” under Article 12 and is consequently “State” for that purpose. The Court held that the Trust was financially, functionally and administratively dominated by or under the control of the Government of India.
The National Book Trust was brought into existence by Government Resolutions dated 15 June 1957 and 28 September 1962. A Full Bench of the Delhi High Court held that the Government exercised deep and pervasive control over the Trust, making it an instrumentality or alter ego of the Government. The Trust challenged this determination before the Supreme Court, arguing that it was a society and that Government grants constituted only one source of its income.
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal. It held that the Trust’s registration as a society did not place it beyond Article 12. The Court noted that the Government appointed the Chairman, nominated members to the governing and Executive Committees, participated in its financial administration and exercised oversight through audit, reporting and approval of alterations to its rules and purposes. The Court clarified that recognising the Trust as “State” under Article 12 would not convert it into a department of the Government or make its employees civil servants.
Key words/phrases: Article 12—Constitution of India, 1950—National Book Trust—Other authorities—Union government—Deep and pervasive control—Financial, functional and administrative domination—Government control over governing composition—Financial administration—CAG audit—Registration as a society—Appeal dismissed
Read the Judgement here.
**********
Grandson’s Claim Over Property in an Intestate Succession
6 November 2026
Citations: 2026 INSC 1208 | 2026 SCO.LR 11(3)[15]
Bench: Justices A.G. Masih and Sunita Agarwal
The Supreme Court held that when a Hindu male dies intestate, property inherited by his son under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 is held in his individual capacity as absolute owner. The grandson has no right by birth in such property.
The appellant’s grandfather, N. Ramakrishnan died without a will. The appellant’s father acquired an 1811 square foot plot after Ramakrishnan’s Class I heirs partitioned his property through a compromise decree dated 1994. In 1997, the father sold the plot to the respondents. The minor appellant filed a suit through his mother seeking partition and a half-share in the land as ancestral coparcenary property. He neither challenged the 1994 compromise nor the 1997 sales deed. The Trial Court granted a preliminary decree for partition. This was reversed by the First Appellate Court and the Madras High Court which held that property devolved under Section 8 is the father’s exclusive property.
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the High Court’s decision. It held that a grandson whose father is alive is not a Class I heir under Section 8. The father becomes the absolute owner of the property with complete power to alienate his share once the property is partitioned.
Key words/phrases: Death of property owner without a will—Property of a male Hindu dying intestate—Section 8—Hindu Succession Act, 1956—Class 1 heirs—Property partitioned after death—Compromise decree—Father acquires 1811 square foot—Sold to respondents—Minor grandson seeks half share in land—Trial Court grants decree in favour of grandson—First appellate court and Madras High Court set aside—Property exclusively with father—Supreme Court appeal—Grandson not a Class 1 heir if father is alive—Madras High Court judgement upheld
Read the Judgement here.