Lighting of Karthigai Deepam | Petitioners conclude arguments seeking interim stay

Lighting of Karthigai Deepam at Thirupparankundram Hill

Judges: Aravind Kumar J, V.M. Pancholi J

The Bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul Pancholi continued hearing arguments by petitioners seeking an interim stay on Madras High Court Division Bench judgement directing lighting of the Karthigai Deepam lamp on the stone pillar, known as Deepathoon. 

The Supreme Court has been hearing arguments for two days. Petitioners argued that there is no religious custom to light the lamp at the Deepathoon and that a writ court cannot introduce a new custom. The Dargah situated on the same hill has also claimed that the Deepathoon stands on its property, relying on a 1923 decree. 

Senior Advocates Narender Hooda and Amit Anand Tiwari appeared for the petitioners seeking a stay on the Madras High Court judgement. Senior Advocate P Valliappan appeared for Rama Ravikumar, the original petitioner, who approached the Madras High Court seeking directions to light the lamp at the Deepathoon.

Hooda: Hill is “secular” in nature

Hooda began his submissions by giving a geographical breakdown of the Hill where the Temple, the Dargha and the Deepathoon are situated. He reiterated that the Nelli Thoppu was Dargah property as per 1923. To its left was the Uchi Pillaiyar temple, the Kashi Vishwanathar temple and ancient Jain caves. To its right stood the Dargah and a flagstaff, on which a flag is hoisted to mark the birthday of a Sufi Saint. He argued that the presence of these different religious sites made the hill “secular” in nature. 

The Deepathoon, or the disputed rock pillar, is slightly to the right of that flag staff. Yesterday, Senior Advocate Huzefa Ahmadi had submitted that the pillar was part of Dargah property, with Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan arguing that the pillar was made for no religious purposes at all but was a survey point during the Great Trigonometrical Survey of India. 

The dispute over lighting the lamp at a different location has been recurring since 1862, Hooda pointed out. That year, a District Court rejected a request to light the lamp atop the hill, holding that no such custom existed, and that permitting it would disturb peace and harmony. Fifty years later, in 1912, a jurisdictional court rejected a similar request for want of established custom, noting that the lamp had been lit at its designated spot for ages. A Civil Suit resulted in the 1923 Decree. A similar writ petition was dismissed in 1996, where parties were directed to approach the statutory authority under the Tamil Nadu Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1959, if they wished to alter the religious practice. Another plea was dismissed in 2014. 

Hooda referred to a request by the Dargah to conduct animal sacrifice on its property in 2025, which was rejected on the ground that the Hill was a protected monument, and that no new religious practice could be introduced without establishing an ancient custom. He argued that requests to alter customs had consistently been restricted, irrespective of the community making them. 

Hooda argued that a devotee cannot seek a writ of mandamus compelling the temple to alter an age-old practice—either by shifting the lamp or lighting it at an additional site. A writ court, he argued, is not the appropriate forum to direct it. 

Criticising the Single Judge’s Order, he stated that the Madras High Court had directed the Temple to assert its proprietary title over the Hill. Referring to the judgement, Hooda argued that there is no question of “restoring” a practice of lighting the lamp at the Deepathoon, as no such practice ever existed. 

Tiwari: An attempt to disturb longstanding communal harmony

Tiwari submitted that the Single Judge had erred in directing the Temple to assert its proprietary rights over the hill. He argued that both the Single and Division Bench of the Madras High Court used a writ forum to assert such a property title, bypassing civil adjudication. Agreeing with Ahmadi’s submission, he took the Bench through a map of the Hill. Referring to a 1978 judgement, he argued that the Court had held that the Temple was not in possession of the top spaces of the hillock and the surrounding top space—Dargah, flagstaff and the rock pillar—all belong to the Mohammedans. 

Referring to the doctrine of res judicata, he submitted that the 1923 Decree, the 1978 judgement and the 1996 judgement directing parties to the statutory authorities under the Charitable Endowments Act had laid down the correct law. Any attempt to reopen the dispute, he argued,t was a mischievous attempt to disturb longstanding communal harmony.

Valliappan: Stone pillar not a survey point

With the petitioners concluding their submissions, the respondents began arguing against an interim stay. Similar to the petitioners, they too undertook a geographical study of the Hill. Valliappan submitted that the hill stood at a height of 1048 feet with the Shiva temple located at the foothills. The Nelli Tophu measures 33 cents and is situated midway, at a height of 450 feet from the foothills. 171 acres belongs to the Temple except for the specific areas demarcated to the Dargah. The flight of steps leading to the Nelli Tophu belongs to the Temple, and the steps after, going upwards towards the Dargah belong to the Mohammedans. 

Valliappan disputed the argument that the Deepathoon was a survey point. He submitted that a standard survey stone would not have a hollow cavity at its top, designed to hold an iron cauldron or bucket containing ghee and cotton wicks. The arrangement, he argued, was specifically to light the Karthigai Deepam for two hours once a year. He showed the Bench photographs of similar pillars across various Tamil Nadu temples, arguing that these are traditional Deepathoons and not survey stones. He submitted that petitioners had been prevented from lighting the lamp and that the prolonged history of litigation could not be used to argue that there was “no custom”. 

Referring to the Dargah, he submitted that the lighting of the lamp will not cause any disturbance, as the petitioners were not seeking permission to light the Deepam inside the Dargah. He added that none of the petitioners seeking stay had demonstrated how the Dargah will be affected if the Deepam is lit at a vantage point for just two hours, once a year. Referring to the events of last year, he claimed that devotees had been prevented from lighting the lamp despite the Madras High Court judgement. The incident had also led to contempt proceedings against the state authorities. 

The Bench will continue hearing arguments at 10:30 am tomorrow.

Exit mobile version