Delhi SIR | SC to review progress before deciding on 30 November deadline
Challenge to the ECI’s Special Intensive Revision of Electoral RollsJudges: Surya Kant CJI, Joymalya Bagchi J, V. Mohana J
Today, the Supreme Court said it would consider whether the late availability of enumeration forms warrants an extension of the 30 November deadline for the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Delhi. The Bench of Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana adjourned the matter to 2 December to assess the progress of the exercise.
Earlier the Bench had questioned the ECI’s requirement that voters marked as shifted or absent file Form 6 to seek inclusion in the draft electoral roll. It observed that existing electors who had merely changed their address within Delhi should be allowed to use Form 8, which is meant for reporting a change of residence. The Court asked the ECI to publish the names of electors it had been unable to contact, along with their previous electoral details, and direct them to their nearest Booth Level Officer.
Advocate Prashant Bhushan, appearing for the petitioners, submitted that the ECI had failed to distribute enumeration forms to electors. He pointed out that the ECI had only yesterday published a facility allowing voters to download blank enumeration forms from its website and submit them after filling them in. Bhushan questioned the timing of the facility, introduced just before the hearing, given the approaching deadline.
Justice Bagchi asked the petitioners to make use of the facility, observing that the question was how effectively the available window was being utilised. He said 2 December would be a better date to take stock of the situation and assess whether further accommodation was necessary. The CJI observed that the deadline could be extended, as had been done earlier, remarking that once deadlines were set, “they are never dead”.
Court seeks data on forms filed
Bhushan asked the Court to direct the ECI to publish details of the Forms 6, 7 and 8 submitted, the action taken on them and the number of electors added to or deleted from the rolls. Justice Bagchi said the petitioners should approach affected individuals on the ground. Acknowledging the concern about institutional opacity, he said the priority was to ensure that the Court’s directions reached electors. “They don’t want to aide a PIL petitioner. Get the individuals,” he remarked. The CJI directed the ECI to furnish consolidated data on Forms 6, 7 and 8 in a tabulated format. Senior Advocate D.S. Naidu, appearing for the ECI, agreed to provide the figures.