Lighting of Karthigai Deepam | Pillar not religious, belongs to Dargah committee; petitioners argue

Lighting of Karthigai Deepam at Thirupparankundram Hill

Judges: Aravind Kumar J, V.M. Pancholi J

Today, a Bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul Pancholi continued hearing arguments on the petitions seeking an interim stay on the Madras High Court judgement directing the lighting of the Karthigai Deepam at the Deepathoom, a stone pillar. 

The Deepathoon is located on the Thirupparankundram Hill that has a Temple and a Dargah on its two peaks. The Deepathoon is located close to the Dargah. The lighting of the lamp at the Deepathoon was directed by a Single Judge of the Madras High Court and then later upheld by the Division Bench of the Madras High Court. 

Senior Advocates Gopal Sankaranarayanan and Huzefa Ahmadi appeared for the Collector and the Dargah Committee respectively. While Sankaranarayanan submitted the pillar was situated on land belonging to the Temple, the Dargah Committee disputed this claim, arguing that the area belonged to the Dargah. 

Yesterday, petitioners argued that an interim stay on the directions was necessary as it would risk disturbing public peace. They informed the Court that Karthigai Deepam 2026 is expected to take place on 24 November.

Sankaranarayanan: The pillar was erected for survey, not religious purposes 

Sankaranarayanan argued that the pillar has no religious connotation or historical association with the practice of lighting the lamp during Karthigai Deepam. He referred to the Great Trigonometrical Survey (GTS) of India to argue that the “so-called Deepathoon” was actually a pillar created as a Survey Station/Survey Point. Senior Advocate Guru Krishnakumar objected stating that the Survey had been cited before the Division Bench by a private person and that the Collector could not endorse that party’s position 

Sankaranarayanan clarified that the State since reviewed the survey agreed with the private party’s position. He added that the state was not aware about the nature of the pillar when it appeared before the Madras High Court. According to him, the State was concerned that other pillars made for the survey would occupy a religious colour on the basis of the Madras High Court decision. When the Bench asked if the State claimed ownership on the pillar, Sankaranarayanan submitted that they asserted no such claim. He referred to a 1923 Decree which noted that the pillar was in the Temple’s land. 

He argued that a writ court should avoid adjudicating on issues of religion and custom. He submitted that the High Court had effectively recognised a new location for the lighting of the lamp, in addition to the Deepa Mandapam where it had been lit for 150 years. He referred to precedents arguing that the claim of lighting the lamp on the Hill at other locations has been rebuffed by both the High Court and the Supreme Court at different occasions. 

Ahmadi: Dargah was not heard, natural justice violated

Ahmadi appeared for the Dargah committee. At the outset, Ahmadi argued that the Dargah committee was not heard before the Single Judge directed the lighting of the lamp at Deepathoon. Even after it was impleaded, it was not given adequate time to present its case. Further, he stated that the Single Judge had personally visited the Hill and recorded that the pillar does not form part of the Dargah land. This was done before the Dargah committee was made a party.

Referring to the 1923 Decree, Ahmadi submitted that Nelli Thoppu situated on the Hill and everything above it belonged to the Mohammedans. The pillar is located above the Nelli Thoppu. He argued that the Dargah Committee could have contested the Single Judge’s findings on the location and ownership of the pillar had it been given notice of the inspection. He added that a constitutional court does not ordinarily conduct such personal visits. 

Ahmadi added that none of the previous judgements concerning the Hill made any reference to the pillar until 2025. He argued that if the pillar had any historical significance, it would have been referred to in the earlier proceedings. 

The Bench will continue hearing arguments tomorrow at 2 PM.

Exit mobile version