Lighting of Karthigai Deepam | Arguments seeking interim stay conclude
Lighting of Karthigai Deepam at Thiruparankundram HillJudges: Aravind Kumar J, V.M. Pancholi J
Today the respondents concluded submissions in challenges seeking an interim stay on the Madras High Court ruling, directing the lighting of lamp during Karthigai Deepam Day on a stone pillar, known as the Deepathoon, on Thiruparankundram Hill.
Over three days of hearings, the Tamil Nadu government submitted that no custom existed for lighting the lamp at the Deepathoon while also submitting that a Dargah located on the hill claimed ownership of the stone pillar as per a 1923 Decree. Further, it contended that judicial precedents denied lighting of the lamp at any other location.
Senior Advocates Guru Krishna Kumar and S. Sriram closed submissions from the respondent side. The Bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul Pancholi stated that they will pronounce an Order at noon.
Kumar: High Court issued a calibrated direction
Kumar argued that the Single and Division Bench of the Madras High Court had crafted a calibrated order: only the Devasthanam officials were permitted to go to the stone pillar on a single day to light the lamp. Such a restricted direction, he argued, does not warrant an interim stay. The lamp is lit on Karthigai Deepam Day for two hours.
Rejecting the Dargah’s ownership claim, Kumar argued that the 1923 decree did not grant the pillar to the Mohammedans. He stated that there are two peaks separated by a wedge. One has the Dargah and the other has the Deepathoon, owned by the temple. Pointing out that temple authorities themselves had covered the pillar with a cloth to prevent devotees from lighting it, he noted that this proved temple ownership, as the Dargah would otherwise have barred temple officials from accessing the spot. Notably, while the Tamil Nadu government maintains that the pillar stands on temple land, the Dargah committee disputes it.
Referring to the Tamil Nadu Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1959, Kumar observed that an Executive Officer can only manage temple properties and lacks jurisdiction to decide religious customs. Consequently, the officer’s refusal to light the lamp was without legal authority.
Countering the res judicata objection, he argued that prior rulings addressed different locations on the hill and never finally adjudicated the use of this specific Deepathoon. He added that authorities considered a proposal to light the Deepathoon in 2014, but they failed to act on it for over a decade. The State cannot now invoke its own inaction to oppose relief.
Sriram: Balance of convenience in favour of asserting proprietary rights
Sriram argued that the Dargah committee conflated the 1923 decree by relying on photographs of a flagpost. He claimed that the Dargah erected this temporary flagpost in 2021, and it is not the original flagpost referenced in the 1923 decree.
He submitted that granting a stay and maintaining status quo at the instance of the “encroacher” defeats the balance of convenience, which strongly favours enforcing established proprietary rights rather than yielding to speculative public-order apprehensions.
The Bench stated that it will pass an order later today on the batch of petitions.