Analysis
Whose rights take precedence? SC to consider traders’ challenge to Delhi protests
As arguments repeatedly overlapped in previous hearings, the Bench sought to streamline proceedings through category-wise listing.

The Supreme Court today sought to streamline proceedings connected to the Delhi protests as arguments and petitions began to overlap. A Bench of Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana decided to hear a traders’ association’s plea concerning protests around Ramlila Maidan alongside the petition filed by CPI(M) General Secretary M.A. Baby on the right to protest.
Traders raise competing rights around Ramlila Maidan
Senior Advocate Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for the traders’ association, submitted that demonstrations around Ramlila Maidan were disrupting wholesale markets in its vicinity. He questioned the decision to notify the ground as a protest site, pointing out that it was situated in the heart of the city. Rohatgi sought notice on an amended writ petition that impleaded additional respondents.
The Bench took the petition on record and directed notice to the newly added respondents, returnable on 27 November. The CJI said the traders’ plea raised questions about balancing the protesters’ right to demonstrate against the rights of those affected. “The first category concerns the right of protesters to protest. Mr. Rohatgi’s matter concerns the rights of others, their competing fundamental rights. Both will have to be taken together,” he said. The two petitions will be heard on 27 November.
Bench separates contempt matters, plans category-wise hearings
Counsel requested that the contempt matters not be interspersed with the other petitions, arguing that they required separate consideration. The Bench agreed, indicating that the remaining categories would be heard on different days, with a gap of about a day between them.
At the previous hearing, the Bench had divided the connected petitions into nine categories and asked counsel to propose a sequence for arguments. The petitions raise a range of issues, including the regulation of protest sites, alleged police excesses, surveillance of demonstrators and the detention of protesters. The category-wise arrangement is intended to allow the Court to take up these distinct issues in an organised sequence. The Registry will notify the remaining hearing dates by tomorrow.