Manasi Shah
Manasi is an associate editor at the Supreme Court Observer.
Manasi Shah's Posts
Analysis
Delhi Pollution Crisis | We have mechanisms but no will to address issues, says Supreme Court
The Court warned that without expertise and staff NCR’s pollution boards remain toothless, regardless of the laws they’re bound by
Analysis
Media narrative affecting professional prospects, argues Allahbadia
The top court extended interim protection to the YouTuber and sought clarity on the status of ongoing investigations in Assam & Maharashtra
Hearing Reports
Constitutionality of Waqf Amendment Act | Day 1: “Many Muslims want private charity, not Waqf Board,“ says Union
The Bench, led by CJI Sanjiv Khanna, contemplated measures to protect the waqf by user properties and ensure a Muslim-majority on Waqf Board
Analysis
Breathless in the Capital
The season’s hearings on air pollution have opened several workstreams for authorities. But can the SC double down on enforcement?
Analysis
Not just a title: India’s Senior Advocate system in global perspective
As we await the SC’s decision on the procedure for Senior Advocate designation, a look at how other common law countries confer seniority
Analysis
Delhi Pollution Crisis | SC calls for mass awareness on solid waste rules, emissions norms
This week, the Court also reviewed Delhi-NCR’s compliance with colour-coded stickers and vehicle pollution rules
Analysis
Delhi Pollution Crisis |“There’s nothing green about them”: SC refuses to lift firecracker ban in NCR
Calling clean air a constitutional right, the Court upheld the cracker ban and demanded compliance reports on stubble burning control
Analysis
Delhi Pollution Crisis | SC clamps down on regulatory delays in power plants and waste management
The top court demanded accountability on emission controls, waste management and compensation for affected workers
Analysis
Supreme Court considers reforms in Senior Advocate designation process
After two days of hearings, the top court reserved judgement in the case to decide if the process needs fine-tuning or a complete overhaul
Analysis
SC hears suo moto case on Lokpal’s jurisdiction over sitting High Court judges
The Court appointed an amicus to assist the proceedings in determining the Lokpal's powers under the 2013 Act
Analysis
SC calls for stricter regulation of warrantless arrests by revenue officers
The Court held that CrPC provisions apply to arrests under GST and Customs laws while clarifying that revenue officers are not “police"
Analysis
The ‘first woman’ problem
A century after winning the right to practice law, women in the highest ranks of the judiciary remain the exception, not the norm
Analysis
Delhi Pollution Crisis | From smoke to solutions: SC calls for reforms in waste management
Top court questioned why Delhi is still drowning in waste nine years after the Waste Management Rules came into force
Analysis
Can the Lokpal probe complaints against High Court judges?
The top court stayed a Lokpal Order which held that judges of HCs established by Acts of Parliament could be investigated by the Lokpal
Hearing Reports
Challenges to Places of Worship Act, 1991 | Day 3: SC says “enough is enough” amidst flood of new pleas
The Court defers hearing the challenge to the Places of Worship Act, citing an overload of petitions and the need for a three judge bench
Analysis
Supreme Court slams YouTuber Ranveer Allahbadia for ‘obscene’ remarks, grants interim protection
As outrage over Allahbadia's remarks spiralled, the top court described his statements as “disgusting”, “filthy”, and “insulting.”
Analysis
Sikkim lottery distributors win service tax case in Supreme Court
The verdict cements states’ control over lottery taxation, closing a long saga of the Union trying to impose service tax on distributors
Analysis
Supreme Court Review 2024: Recognising ‘substantive equality’ to address systemic barriers
As India grapples with its myriad social challenges, the Court’s rulings pushed for substantive equality rather than ‘sameness’
Analysis
Supreme Court Review 2024: Upholding religious & cultural rights in a polarising environment
What does secularism mean in a land of a thousand faiths? This year's rulings on religion and culture attempt to frame an answer
Analysis
“Shocking state of affairs”: SC slams authorities for inaction on anti-pollution measures
The Court asked for greater accountability from state authorities on waste management, construction worker disbursements & firecrackers
Analysis
Supreme Court’s evolving role in mitigating Delhi’s air pollution crisis
With improving air quality, the top court is shifting focus from damage control to long-term sustainability
Analysis
Monthly Review: November 2024
The month was eventful with CJI D.Y. Chandrachud passing the baton to Sanjiv Khanna and the Court delivering several landmark rulings
Hearing Reports
Altering Rules on Appointment to Public Posts | Judgement Summary
A five-judge bench affirmed that changing rules of public recruitment midway through the process violates constitutional rights
Analysis
Gaps in GRAP: SC pushes for accountability and action
Judicial scrutiny of the pollution crisis highlights systemic failures, poor coordination, & the challenges in enforcing emergency measures
Analysis
“No earnest effort to implement…”: SC cracks down on negligence amid Delhi’s pollution crisis
A Division Bench bench flagged GRAP violations in Delhi, questioning police and state inaction as pollution continues to choke the capital
Analysis
Delhi pollution crisis: Can the Supreme Court clear the air?
A Division Bench appointed 13 advocates as Court Commissioners to ensure compliance with the ban on trucks at Delhi checkpoints
Analysis
Perception and direction: The public engagements of Chief Justice Chandrachud
His frequent public appearances and charismatic personality invited unprecedented attention to an opaque institution
Analysis
Monthly Review: October 2024
October was an active month at the top court with two Constitution Bench decisions and critical Division Bench hearings on personal liberty
Analysis
“Different people with diverse views will continue the institution”: CJI DY Chandrachud retires
As CJI DY Chandrachud retires from the top court, a Ceremonial Bench gathered to bid him farewell