Analysis

A crack in the Collegium’s wall of secrecy

Justice Nagarathna’s reported dissent against a recent recommendation highlights the lack of transparency around Collegium deliberations

Cases | Presidential Reference | Hearing Report

Executive heads cannot exercise legislative powers, states opposing the Reference argue

The states of West Bengal, Karnataka and Himachal Pradesh stressed the significance of the aid and advice of the Council of Minister

SCO.LR

SCO.LR | 2025 | Volume 9 | Issue 1

In this Issue of SCO.LR, we bring you five important judgements from 25 August to 30 August 2025

Analysis | commentary

Final until it’s not: The Supreme Court’s beating retreat

The Court’s quick reversals in three recent cases raise questions about procedure, legitimacy, and finality

Analysis | Desk Brief

Old verdict, new divisions

In the recent debate around VP candidate Justice Reddy’s 2011 verdict in the Salwa Judum case, Maoism is the straw man

Book Excerpt | [In]Complete Justice

How the Aadhaar case remained on ice

In this excerpt from a longer essay, Usha Ramanthan details delays and flagrant violations of judicial orders in the UIDAI litigation

Presidential Reference on Powers of the Governor and President

Pending

Re: Assent, Withholding, or Reservation of Bills by the Governor and President of India

A five-judge Constitution Bench will examine a Presidential reference that questions the Court's authority to impose deadlines for the Governor and President under Articles 200 and 201 of the Constitution.

Challenge to the ECI’s Revision of Electoral Rolls in Bihar

Pending

Association for Democratic Reforms v Election Commission of India

The Supreme Court will decide if the ECI’s Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of Bihar’s electoral rolls is arbitrary and unconstitutional

Reasonable Work Hours for Resident Doctors

Pending

United Doctors Front v Union of India

The Supreme Court will decide if continued violation of duty-hour norms breach resident doctors’ fundamental rights under Article 21

Subscribe to SCO