Sarthak Gupta

Sarthak Gupta's Posts

Analysis

Part 2 | Andrabi engages with the Union’s deferring tactic in UAPA bail cases

The Union’s approach to defer bail pleas by a year was rejected by the Bench, paving the way for bail under the stringent statute

Analysis

Part 1 | Andrabi’s unprecedented reliance on conviction data for granting bail under UAPA

The UAPA reference on the face of it has to only weigh the liberty consideration. Five years worth of cases suggest more nuances

Analysis

Bones, belief and the burden of proof

Revisiting the Nithari killings and the Supreme Court’s curative turn

Analysis

Umar Khalid bail case: Constitutional abdication, not judicial restraint

By denying bail to Khalid and Sharjeel Imam, the Supreme Court could have precipitated a doctrinal shift with implications for undertrials

Court Data

The SC on bail under UAPA and PMLA: a dataset from 2024 and 2025

As the Supreme Court considers the bail plea of Umar Khalid, here’s a ready-reckoner of relevant verdicts from the last couple of years

Analysis

Article 21 remains a divided promise in the Supreme Court’s bail jurisprudence

The selective reading of liberty in UAPA and PMLA cases hinges on the accused’s identity. A ‘Khalid Test’ could offer a course correction