journal | Analysis

Reservation for EWS: 5 Must Reads

journal | Analysis

Will EWS Reservation Survive?

Latest

View all
September

Analysis

SCO.LR | 2025 | Volume 9 | Issue 2

In this Issue of SCO.LR, we bring you five important judgements from 1 September to 6 September 2025

SCO Team

8th Sep 2025

Tamil Nadu

Analysis

Tamil Nadu argues, once again

If the Court expands the scope of the Governor’s discretion under Article 200—even in an advisory opinion—it could open a can of worms

Advay Vora

7th Sep 2025

Analysis

The Constitution of India turns 75: A Diamond Jubilee Commemoration

The Bar Association of India launched a commemorative volume in collaboration with the Supreme Court Observer

SCO Team

4th Sep 2025

Analysis

What is the role of ‘constitutional morality’ in legal interpretation?

In this excerpt from a longer essay, Senior Advocate Gopal Subramanium writes that Indian courts developed this tool to uphold rights

basic structure

Analysis

How the Supreme Court used the Basic Structure Doctrine in the EWS judgement

This excerpt from a longer essay analyses why the Court held that reservation based on economic criteria was valid

Analysis

Umar Khalid’s Bail Application Tracker

A year after Umar Khalid appealed a Trial Court order that had denied him bail, the Delhi High Court rejected his bail plea

SCO Team

4th Sep 2025

Collegium

Analysis

A crack in the Collegium’s wall of secrecy

Justice Nagarathna’s reported dissent against a recent recommendation highlights the lack of transparency around Collegium deliberations

View all

From the editor's desk

The differential levels of scrutiny the Court applies to studies on caste vis-a-vis economic backwardness may have deep and abiding implications for how affirmative action policies are crafted in the future, and is especially prescient in a situation where challenges to EWS reservations remain pending.
Can the Supreme Court Provide Reservations for Orphans?

With the petition seeking orphans to be identified as a backward class, are we moving away from a caste centric definition of backwardness.

Part I—The Mandal and Sinho Commissions: A Study in Contrasts

There is a marked difference in the methodology employed by the Mandal and Major Sinho Commissions in studying backwardness.

SC Offers Hope for OBC Reservations in Maharashtra Municipal Elections

The Maharashtra government was directed to submit data justifying its OBC reservation policy to the State Commission for Backward Castes.

Medical Students Relieved as SC Issues Order in PG NEET Case

DESK BRIEF: The SC issued an Order allowing the Union to immediately commence counselling for admissions to postgraduate medical programmes.