journal | Analysis

Reservation for EWS: 5 Must Reads

journal | Analysis

Will EWS Reservation Survive?

Latest

View all

Analysis

Old verdict, new divisions

In the recent debate around VP candidate Justice Reddy’s 2011 verdict in the Salwa Judum case, Maoism is the straw man

Analysis

Do former judges make better arbitrators?

In this excerpt from his essay on the SC and arbitration, Amit George details pressing issues around judicial intervention and restraint

Amit George

28th Aug 2025

Analysis

How the Aadhaar case remained on ice

In this excerpt from a longer essay, Usha Ramanthan details delays and flagrant violations of judicial orders in the UIDAI litigation

Court's

Analysis

Final until it’s not: The Supreme Court’s beating retreat

The Court’s quick reversals in three recent cases raise questions about procedure, legitimacy, and finality

SCOLR

Analysis

SCO.LR | 2025 | Volume 8 | Issue 4

In this Issue of SCO.LR, we bring you five important judgements from 18 August to 23 August 2025

SCO Team

25th Aug 2025

Ali Khan Mahmudabad Supreme Court

Analysis

‘Persecuting people in the country, that’s what you’re doing’: Kapil Sibal asks as SC quashes FIR against professor Ali Khan Mahmudabad

The Court held that no offence by Mahmudabad was disclosed in the FIR, barred the courts from taking cognisance of the chargesheet

Analysis

Samay Raina, Sonali Thakkar and other comedians must publish unconditional apology online, Supreme Court Orders

The Court deliberated on the guidelines for online speech to avoid future instances that could hurt the sentiments of certain groups

Advay Vora

25th Aug 2025

View all

From the editor's desk

The differential levels of scrutiny the Court applies to studies on caste vis-a-vis economic backwardness may have deep and abiding implications for how affirmative action policies are crafted in the future, and is especially prescient in a situation where challenges to EWS reservations remain pending.
Can the Supreme Court Provide Reservations for Orphans?

With the petition seeking orphans to be identified as a backward class, are we moving away from a caste centric definition of backwardness.

Part I—The Mandal and Sinho Commissions: A Study in Contrasts

There is a marked difference in the methodology employed by the Mandal and Major Sinho Commissions in studying backwardness.

SC Offers Hope for OBC Reservations in Maharashtra Municipal Elections

The Maharashtra government was directed to submit data justifying its OBC reservation policy to the State Commission for Backward Castes.

Medical Students Relieved as SC Issues Order in PG NEET Case

DESK BRIEF: The SC issued an Order allowing the Union to immediately commence counselling for admissions to postgraduate medical programmes.